Welcome to a world of unlimited cognitive dissonance
Wolfgang Knorr is a climate scientist, consultant for the European Space Agency and guest researcher at the Department of Geography and Ecosystem Science, Lund University
Cross-posted from Wolfgang’s Substack Climate Uncensored

Photo: Big Think / Jacob Hege
Before I embarked on a career in climate science, I had a brief encounter with the world of physics research. It was brief, but at least we had a Nobel laureate on the floor, who was considered a little bit crazy, but a genius nonetheless. And that’s what you learn in physics – that crazy ideas exist, and that it may be completely sane and acceptable to discuss them seriously. One of those ideas is the theory of the multiverse.
It’s an idea that is not new, but it has recently become quite a relevant point of reference that may help us understand what is going on in the world. The idea of the multiverse is simple. The entire world is not just made up of one universe – a word that basically means “everything” – but of many, even an infinite number of “everythings”. The “multiverse” then is the entirety of the many “universes” that supposedly exist. So in one universe, your favourite sports team always loses, but there is another, parallel one, where they always win. Or another, where the Earth rotates the other way around. And so on. The catch – by definition, you cannot observe other universes, because if you could, they would not constitute separate universes. So the theory is essentially unverifiable.
If that all sounds crazy and a waste of time, then that is because it is so. But the very fact that such ideas are being seriously discussed may lead us to look at another phenomenon – the idea of the social multiverse. For example, physicists and philosophers discussing the physical multiverse are clearly living in a separate universe compared to ordinary folk on a nine-to-five job worrying about bills, or how their kids are doing at school. There is no cross-observation, and nothing happening in one universe has any effect on the other. Now, the point I am trying to make here is that something very similar is happening with that socially constructed event commonly referred to as the “climate crisis”.
To understand the multiverse climate crisis theory, all we have to do is look at a few news items coming out of the apparently “identical” COP31 currently happening in Antalya – the annual Conference Of the Parties of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. The first is from the Guardian, and presents us with a newly emerged Greta Thunberg telling us that we shouldn’t view planet Earth as a – sadly – dying patient, but as victim that we have been killing ourselves bit by bit. The second news item is from Semafor Energy, a newsletter for the energy industry. It reads: “Selloffs in global markets and investor nervousness about the AI buildout […] is just going to be a blip,” said the CEO of Acwa [at COP31], one of the world’s top clean energy developers. “The demand is there”. And the third another newsletter sent today, this time from the Fossil Fuel Treaty Organisation, reporting that “At a high-level party press conference at COP31, Ministers announced that the Bloc of Nations developing a Fossil Fuel Treaty has grown to 30 states.” The Fossil Fuel Treaty aims at banning the use of fossil fuels.
To understand the social and political reality of the climate crisis, we need to see that these three news items constitute not just different perspectives, but views from completely different socially constructed universes. There is essentially no cross-communication or even just cross-observation. So let’s consider them one by one.
Greta Thunberg’s remarks obviously refer to what she has been saying ever since the massacre of defenceless civilians in Gaza escalated info a full-scale genocide, and for which she has been largely shunned by legacy media as “anti-semitic”: that “climate” is just one form of a much wider issue of unfathomable violence against the weak, that dropping 2000 pound bombs on tents where the children of refugees are sleeping, and the devastation of the natural environment brought about by industrial activity are just two sides of the same coin. And, I may add, genocide and the targeted killing of children, dehumanised as the feared offspring of the “other” embedded in a conflict over land, this is exactly the face of the climate disaster awaiting us. Not just hurricanes, droughts or heat waves. The message, delivered to the delegates at COP31 and broadcast worldwide, couldn’t be clearer.
Enter another message, also broadcast at COP31. It is a message of untethered optimism, where the little details cannot possible muddle the bright long-term outlook. The reason for the optimism is the prospect of massive profits from inexorably rising electricity demand, driven by AI and so-called “data centres” (which really should be called compute-centres). In this context, “renewable energy” explicitly includes natural gas, which, when accounting for the climate effects of methane leakage, has roughly the same warming effect per unit of electricity as coal, the dirty kid of electricity production. This is a Saudi owned energy company using COP31 as a trade show, selling gas as climate friendly and proving, by explicitly mentioning the AI energy boom, what critics of climate optimism have been saying all along: even real renewables, such as solar and wind, do not replace fossil fuels, but add to them.
The last news item is by an organisation not concerned with profits, but with actual workable solutions in the context of the real world. The idea is to start by building a “coalition of the willing” with the aim to ban fossil fuels, modelled on international treaties of arms control. Characteristically, Tzeporah Berman, its founder, does not expect the US, historically the biggest emitter of heat-trapping carbon dioxide, to join any time soon, but forges ahead anyway. It also follows an approach that has always been missing because of largely hidden industry lobbying: reducing not the demand for, but the supply of fossil fuels. Berman has received death threats from the tar sands industry when campaigning locally in Canada.
It is worth while to read all three stories and take them in fully. Because then we can feel, in us, unfold the logic of each of the three separate narratives. Truth telling and compassion – the optimism of the strong – real-world, fearless campaignin. Each contains its own truth, but the more important thing is that they do not talk to each other, even if they unfold in the same conference centre.
That’s why the story of the multiverse is also the story of what is often called cognitive dissonance. Essentially separate worlds exist side by side, in the same conference, in the same newspaper, or even in one and the same person. During my career, travelling by train in the UK before the advent of smartphones, I remember often reading some article about the climate or other environmental crisis that would inevitably be printed side by side with some advertisement for cheap flights or distant holiday destinations. Or I would observe that people would rarely actually talk about the climate crisis, even though many, when questioned, would declare grave concern. And in the world of climate science, the concern is often more about getting published, than about being listened to by the public. So in myself, there was the concerned, scared citizen who could see the enormous forces unleashed, and side by side the research scientist compelled to write important sounding journal articles, as well as the father responsible for raising my children. In fact, even before I entered climate science, I remember seeing that the issue was not as clear-cut as it looked. When telling someone that I had just received an offer for a PhD programme in one of the world’s then few leading climate modelling centres, for some reason I reacted coolly to the suggestion I was going to do humanity a service. I had already encountered the self-serving world of academia and didn’t believe there would necessary be a link to a universe of ethical thinking and acting.
What I am describing here is a phenomenon of polarisation and societal disintegration that certainly has had its fair share of attention. But what is still worth noting is that what we are looking at now is not just polarisation, or diverging views, but the breakdown of any form of contact between separate worlds. It’s as if the fabric of our society of entering a new physical state, transforming from a fluid network to solid block of rigid sub-entities. The level of cognitive dissonance in our current western society continues to reach ever new heights – with climate protesters and anti-genocide group sympathisers charged with terrorism for participating in zoom calls, or holding up hand written placards. If you are within the state apparatus, everything that from outside appears outrageous, suddenly sounds perfectly reasonable.
The disintegration is in most likelihood a symptom of societal collapse that has to do with us hitting the limits of our planetary carrying capacity. Knowing that, however, doesn’t really help. But what we can do is acknowledge the existence of the separate “real” universes, gain a more integrated view of our current crises, understand why and how fragmentation works against us, and within all this chaos seek out our place and our community.
____________________________________


Be the first to comment