Raphaël Schmeller – Fall in Line, or Pay the Price

Sanctions: The EU has targeted the German journalist Hüseyin Doğru. Did he support Russia’s destabilising activities?

Raphaël Schmeller is a German-French journalist resident in Berlin

Cross-posted from Hüseyin Dogru’s Substack

This article was written by Raphaël Schmeller for der Freitag, published in print on 19 November 2026. Translated from German into English by Hüseyin Dogru.

“Free press: protecting what matters to us.” This is the slogan on EU posters in Brussels, Berlin and elsewhere. The message is that Europe should be a place where journalists can work freely and hold state power to account. In early November, the campaign warned that journalists are being watched, intimidated and put under economic pressure. Yet this claim sits uneasily with the EU’s own policy.

Since 20 May 2025, Hüseyin Doğru, a German journalist living in Berlin, has been on the EU sanctions list for allegedly supporting “Russia’s destabilising activities”. On 8 October, the measures were extended for another year, even though he is not accused of any crime. His accounts and assets therefore remain frozen, and his freedom to travel remains restricted.

The sanctions have turned Doğru’s daily life upside down. From January, he says, he will face “an existential threat”, with 506 euros a month to live on. That is the amount he is allowed to draw from his frozen assets as a subsistence minimum, and it directly affects a family of five: Doğru, his wife and their three young children. Brussels considers the measures proportionate. When asked, an EU official said the sanctions do not prevent him from working as a journalist, and a Commission spokeswoman stressed that freedom of expression is not unlimited. The sanctions are “temporary and reversible”, she said, and their main aim is a “change in behaviour”.

What behaviour is Doğru supposed to change? He is accused of spreading “systematically false information” through AFA Medya and the platform RED, of taking up Hamas narratives, and of cooperating with pro-Palestinian protesters during the occupation of Humboldt University in May 2024. In doing so, the EU says, he supported Russian “destabilisation activities”. It also alleges that RED has close ties to Russian state media.

Doğru rejects these accusations. He confirms that he used to work for Redfish, which was funded through the Russian news agency Ruptly, but says he cut those ties when Russia’s war against Ukraine began. “If you look at my work, you can see that I criticised this war and repeatedly called it an invasion.” He also denies having any links to Moscow today. The evidence files he was given contain “no intelligence report, nothing” to support this, he says.

The EU has not presented any publicly verifiable evidence of the alleged connections. In its legal view, it does not have to prove them. It is enough for a person to support or facilitate actions attributed to Russia. Nor does the sanctioned conduct have to be punishable: the European External Action Service defines “Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference” as a “mostly non-illegal pattern of behaviour”. The European Council can rely on media reports and other sources without waiting for investigations or court proceedings. Because the EU sees its sanctions as preventive rather than criminal measures, it holds that the presumption of innocence does not apply. This is exactly what makes the case so problematic for the rule of law. The EU points out that those affected can challenge their listing before the European courts, as Hüseyin Doğru did in July 2025. Until a ruling is made, however, the sanctions stay in force.

Penalties are imposed without an EU court having reviewed the legal situation

A legal opinion presented in the European Parliament by former judge Ninon Colneric and international law scholar Alina Miron describes individual sanctions like these as a de facto “civil death”. Assets are frozen, and access to banking and the ability to function economically are largely blocked, all without any prior judicial review. The two lawyers warn that the intention is to deter journalists. After all, they argue, it remains unclear where legitimate reporting ends and “information manipulation” begins.

A legal opinion presented in the European Parliament by former judge Ninon Colneric and international law scholar Alina Miron describes individual sanctions like these as a de facto “civil death”. Assets are frozen, and access to banking and the ability to function economically are largely blocked, all without any prior judicial review. The two lawyers warn that the intention is to deter journalists. After all, they argue, it remains unclear where legitimate reporting ends and “information manipulation” begins.

Doğru’s lawyer, Alexander Gorski, says the conditions for sanctioning his client have not been met. “Hüseyin Doğru has no ties to the Russian Federation. He is an independent journalist.” He calls the EU’s claim that Doğru can still work as a journalist “absolutely laughable”. Potential employers, he says, cannot get a clear answer from the German government on whether paying him would count as a sanctions breach with criminal consequences.

Equally striking is the position of the German Union of Journalists (dju), part of the trade union Verdi, which sees no violation of press freedom. “Propaganda media organised by a foreign state” cannot claim its protection, a Verdi spokesperson said. At the same time, the union admits that the case is “unresolved in key respects”. It does not say what evidence the dju itself has examined.

In August, the union’s own media, journalism and film section for Berlin-Brandenburg voted by a majority to call for the sanctions to be reviewed and lifted. The dju’s national executive rejected this, citing the principle of “militant democracy” (wehrhafte Demokratie). A journalists’ union is therefore backing the sanctions instrument in a case it itself calls unresolved, instead of pressing for verifiable evidence and the protection of press freedom.

Human rights organisations have also protested only to a limited extent so far. Amnesty International is aware of the case and says it is in contact with Doğru’s lawyer. Whether the sanctions are proportionate needs to be examined, it says, but a detailed statement is not possible at the moment. Reporters Without Borders was likewise unable to answer questions about the case “for capacity reasons”. After a year and a half of sanctions, this reticence is remarkable. Gorski speaks of a precedent: “It is shocking to see how sanctions law is being used to silence a German journalist living in Germany.”

_____________________________________

Pledge für Hüseyin’s Substack

To do so, go HERE

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*