Chris Bambery – The divide between the State of Israel and the State of Judea is not insignificant

Divisions within Zionism will play an important role in its eventual downfall.

Chris Bambery is an author, political activist and commentator, and a supporter of Rise, the radical left wing coalition in Scotland. His books include A People’s History of Scotland and The Second World War: A Marxist Analysis.

Cross-posted from Counterfire

In an article here earlier this month I wrote, “it is worth asking how long pre-1967 Israel will remain a parliamentary democracy,” I went on to quote a classified CIA assessment, produced in August of this year, that warns Israel is at risk of civil war or state collapse because of internal tensions – economic crisis and soaring military spending

A number of readers were puzzled why I should argue this. Benjamin Netanyahu seems gone and a new government, which will likely include two Arab parties, will be greeted with sighs of relief in ruling circles in North America and Europe. Above all Israel is still committing genocide in Gaza, ethnically cleansing the West Bank and occupies southern Lebanon and parts of Syria.

However the CIA is right in that Israel is dangerously polarised. The very idea Arab parties might enter government has literally driven the Israeli right mad. It underlines a deep divide between what the Israeli anti-Zionist historian Ilan Pappe called the State of Israel and the State of Judea.

Pappe offers this description of the State of Israel:

“It comprises more secular, liberal and mostly but not exclusively middle-class European Jews and their descendants, who were instrumental in establishing the state in 1948 and remained hegemonic within it until the end of the last century. Make no mistake, their advocacy of ‘liberal democratic values’ does not affect their commitment to the apartheid system which is imposed, in various ways, on all Palestinians living between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. Their basic wish is for Jewish citizens to live in a democratic and pluralist society from which Arabs are excluded.”

I would add that leading figures in the State of Israel were responsible for the 1948 Nakba, David Ben Gurion, Israel’s first prime minister particularly, and for the ethnic cleansing which accompanied the 1967 Six Day War, prime minister Golda Meir in particular. Both belonged to the Israeli Labour Party which ruled the state uninterruptedly from 1948 until 1977.

As for the State of Judea, Pappe describes thus:

“[It] developed among the settlers of the occupied West Bank. It enjoys increasing levels of support within the country and constitutes the electoral base that secured Netanyahu’s victory in the November 2022 elections. Its influence in the upper echelons of the Israeli army and security services is growing exponentially. The State of Judea wants Israel to become a theocracy that stretches over the entirety of historical Palestine. To achieve this, it is determined to reduce the number of Palestinians to a bare minimum, and it is contemplating the construction of a Third Temple in place of the  al-Aqsa mosque. Its members believe this will enable them to renew the golden era of the Biblical Kingdoms. For them, secular Jews are as heretical as the Palestinians if they refuse to join in this endeavour.”

Its roots go back to ultra-Zionist politician, Ze’ev Jabotinsky, the founder of Revisionist Zionism, which would form the bedrock of Netanyahu’s Likud party. In his 1923 essay, the ‘Iron Wall’,  Jabotinsky argued a Jewish state could only be created from a position of overwhelming military strength, by proving in arms to the Palestinians and the Arab states, that Zionism could not be defeated. Israel then had to construct an Iron Wall around Greater Israel – that would include Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem – to ensure it would never be attacked. All Palestinians had to be removed from Greater Israel.

But Jabotinsky and his heirs see liberal Jews as an enemy. They want to create a theocratic state based on religious law not a parliamentary democracy even if it’s only one for Jewish citizens of Israel. All LGBT rights would go, women would be reduced to being simply wives and mothers and religious courts would enforce the law. All secular Jews would have to convert to orthodox Judaism.

Since 7 October 2023 more than half a million Israelis, citizens of the State of Israel, have left the country. In a nation of just just over 10 million, with Jews forming 78.3  percent of that population that tips the balance more and more towards the State of Judea.

Those who have left are younger and highly educated. Crucial to Israel’s high tech industries, particularly high tech arms exports. This has long term implications for its economy.

The state of Israel long rested on a supposedly moral basis: Firstly that after the Holocaust a Jewish state was the only haven from anti-semitism; second, that Israel was created in the ancient Jewish homeland which for cultural and historical reasons belonged to the Jews.

The presence of an indigenous population, the Palestinians, was initially denied – thus the slogan “a  land without a people for a people without a land,” coined by a Church of Scotland minister, Alexander Keith.

When the Israel had to recognise the existence of Palestinians it demonised them and subjected them to both racism and repression.

Then, the state of Israel, repeatedly declaring it was the  “only democracy in the Middle East,” presented itself as a generous peacemaker who was willing to resolve the problem by offering ‘concessions’ over its supposed right to the whole of historical Palestine. The so-called two state solution was a sham from the moment the ink dried on the 1993 Oslo Agreement which no Israeli government has implemented.

Even this was too much for the State of Judea. Right wing parties, such as Likud and national-religious factions, viewed Judea and Samaria (the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza) as integral parts of the historic land of Israel, arguing that any withdrawal or division compromised divine or national rights.

The people of Judea do not care about international legitimacy. They could easily adopt Millwall FC’s chant, “No one likes us but we don’t care.” But they are impressed by Israel’s new allies on the far right from Hindu fundamentalists to open fascists like Tommy Robinson.

As the State of Judea has gained ground it has penetrated into the Israeli Defence Force and the security service.

Across Europe we are currently witnessing a youth revolt against neo-liberalism, war and in support of Palestine. There is no youth rebellion to the left in Israel. But there is Generation Right.

In October’s general election three quarters of Jewish first-time voters identified as right or centre-right, higher than the rest of Israeli society. The party which got the biggest share of their vote was National Security Minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir’s party Otzma Yehudit (Jewish Power).

Otzma Yehudit is rooted among the Hardal (National Religious Haredi) movement which does not offer unequivocal support to the Israeli state and its secular institutions. They embrace the strict observance and rejection of modernity characteristic of ultra-Orthodoxy. These Hardalim are typically found in hardline settlements like Beit El and Kedumim in the West Bank.

The pogroms in the West Bank are spearheaded by : No’ar HaGva’ot (the Hilltop Youth). It’s made up of decentralised communities of teenagers and young adults in the occupied territories. They generally reject both the political and religious establishments, incorporating hassidic teachings and practices while adhering to their own standards of ‘authenticity.’ Their residence in hilltop outposts deemed illegal by the State of Israel highlights their rebellious and fringe ethos. They do not recognise the authority of the Knesset.

The Israeli government formally deplores their attacks but does nothing to stop them. The Israeli Defence Force abets them.

Indeed, under the Netanyahu coalition government they have an effective free hand. The United Nations recorded more than 1,330 settler attacks during the first half of 2026, which Palestinian rights groups say is a conservative estimate. These activities include vandalism, arson, physical and sexual assaults against Palestinians.

Bezalel Smotrich is both Finance Minister and a Minister in the Defence Ministry. In the latter role, he has authority over ‘civilian issues in the West Bank’ including over the allocation of land and the planning and construction of illegal settlements. Smotrich himself lives on an illegal settlement, and believes that the occupied territories are part of Israel. For him Palestinians must ‘choose’ between a life of subjugation under Israeli rule, voluntary emigration or death. A notorious racist who proudly describes himself as a ‘fascist homophobe’, Smotrich is an ultra-nationalist who denies the existence of Palestistine as a nation or people.

National Security Minister, Ben-Gvir was convicted in 2007 for inciting racism and supporting a terrorist organisation. That has not stopped him being a government minister.

Into this mix let’s add that there are approximately 335,000 to 400,000 total legal civilian firearm license holders in Israel. That’s rocketed up since 7 October 2023.

The State of Judea will not recognise a government which includes Arab parties.

This is a recipe for civil war or at least the destabilisation of the Zionist state.

One effect of nationalist violence in Israel will be to accelerate the detachment of American Jews, particularly younger ones, from Zionism. That does not seem to concern the right in Israel but it’s a potential game changer in the US upon which Israel relies for its security.

In December 1948, Albert Einstein, Hannah Arendt, and other prominent American Jews sent a letter to The New York Times warning against the rise of Menachem Begin’s Freedom Party (Tnuat Haherut)—the precursor to modern Israel’s Likud party.

Their letter explicitly characterised the Freedom Party as “closely akin in its organisation, methods, political philosophy and social appeal to the Nazi and Fascist parties,” noting that its leaders preached ultra-nationalism, religious mysticism, and racial superiority.

Their warning is even more relevant to today’s Israel.

KEEP RESISTANCE MEDIA ALIVE IN 2027

To donate please go HERE.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*